Iain Hall's SANDPIT

Home » Blogging » To Give or not to give, that is the question…

To Give or not to give, that is the question…

Giving is not simple

I have been known to mock Damian Doyle (aka Toaf) because he seems to spend an inordinate amount of time  looking for one new disaster or human tragedy so that he can suggest that we should all either feel terrible guilt that we are living in plush western affluence, or a deep shame that we don’t automatically divest ourselves of all worldly possessions and give money till it hurts. I like to suggest that his interest in  world wide suffering makes him a fan of “disaster Porn”.

Personally I tend to think that charity begins at home and I am far more inclined to support causes that are  more local. Yet it is the malaise of the modern left to think that their guilt chips can be made quiet by the constant giving of alms.
So I found the piece in today’s age rather interesting it rather neatly lays out the dilemma inherent in our interconnected world, caused in part by the 24 hour global news cycle. Not a week goes by without there being news of some new natural or man made disaster. I think that it is only natural that we all eventually become rather immune to the images of suffering on the TV. Likewise I have absolutely no time for the constant calls from charity organisations seeking donations I have developed a standard replay along the lines of “As a matter of policy I do not donate to any organisation who cold call me” and it seems to give them the message with out being too nasty that I don’t appreciate their begging. Anyway this ramble is by way of an introduction to the OP  Ed piece that I found in today’s age by Maria Tumarkin:


Maria Tumarkin

But wait, should you be giving money to the Pakistan appeal when you walk past homeless people in your city every day, when eight young indigenous people killed themselves in the Northern Territory recently, and when traumatised children have been exposed to intolerable levels of anxiety, distress and self-harm in detention centres?

Actually, should you be giving money to strangers (assuming a part of your donation reaches those strangers in the first place) when your own sister cannot pay rent or your own grandparents are struggling on a government pension? Is this not the height of hypocrisy to look away from the needs of those closest to you, to judge them less pressing and serious than the needs of people on the other side of the world?

AND I am not even going into the serious critiques of foreign aid as a whole, such as the one recently put forward by economist Dambisa Moyo in her book Dead Aid (Oprah loves it!). Moyo is hardly the first to argue that societies become trapped in aid dependency, which perpetuates disempowerment and endemic corruption, and gives rise to more poverty and dependency still. (In the same way Noel Pearson, love him or hate him, has argued that welfare dependency has trapped and poisoned indigenous communities across Australia.) In his recent public lecture Against Charity, philosopher Slavoj Zizek proclaims that in the West charity has been swallowed whole by cultural capitalism (see, for instance, the rise of the so-called philanthrocapitalism) and altruism has been subsumed by consumerism so the two can no longer be pulled apart – buy Starbucks coffee and support free-trade coffee producers; choose organic and save the planet; shop here and say a decisive no to child labour.


In my younger days there were probably no fewer natural disasters, no fewer wars and definitely no more instances of individual suffering its just that the news of events and the vision of that disarray and the faces of the starving are there in our living rooms day in and day out. Oh I know this is sort of the opposite of the “If a tree falls in the Forrest“riddle because we hear the sound of suffering so much that  so much we no longer seem to notice any individual instance of pain.

Anyway Maria Tumarkin’s column is thought provoking and worth reading

Cheers Comrades






  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Gig, Iain Hall. Iain Hall said: To Give or not to give, that is the question…: #toaf http://wp.me/p1ZH5-2mc […]

  2. Diane says:

    Charity begins at home, absolutely! I’d much rather donate money to a local cause than buy a goat to feed a family of 10 in Africa. I’m a committed buyer of “The Big Issue” here in Melbourne (it’s a great read) but will not give money to beggars in the city who sit there with their cardboard, dog, dyed hair and fag in mouth (if you’re that poor how can you afford to feed a dog, dye your hair and smoke???). That aside I will donate to charities where all the donation goes to the charity (not the 80 cents in the dollar which goes to the person rattling the tin) and will question any charity stall in my local shopping centre on how much of my donation will actually go to the charity, you’d be surprised how much doesn’t.

  3. SockPuppet says:

    Maria’s nice.

  4. gigdiary says:

    Dianne, is the Big Issue legit for support? I apologise in advance for my ignorance.

    I agree with you and Iain on this one. I have recently crossed swords with a young nascent writer, published once or twice on the Drum, who promotes overseas aid causes, yet whenever an issue arises with the indigenous in the Territory, or the homeless in Sydney, she is silent.

    I’ll venture a suggestion that the latte-sippers find it a whole lot more palatable and self aggrandising to sit around at dinner parties boasting of their contribution to Overseas Aid rather than say they gave a homeless shelter some money.

    On an aside, I wouldn’t begrudge anyone a pack of rollies. I don’t smoke, but for anyone on the street, homeless or just trying for a few bucks, that probably is the only pleasure they have.

  5. Iain Hall says:

    Diane & GD
    I hardly ever get into the inner city so I never have an opportunity to buy copies of the Big Issue but on principle I agree that buying that is a better than supporting less industrious beggars.
    I also don’t think less of a homeless person for smoking.I found this picture rather funny and refreshingly honest 😉

  6. gigdiary says:

    Trouble is, that fellow looks fit, young and robust. Why is he begging? Perhaps he could get a job as a signwriter…

  7. Diane says:

    Ha ha, excellent pics Iain.
    True about the smoking, I suppose it is their only pleasure, slap on the wrist for me!!
    Gigdiary, The Big Issue is sold by vendors at a cost of $5, of which $2.50 goes into their pocket and the rest to the magazine for publishing costs. We have a couple of homeless guys who attend my church and they feel they have better self respect by selling the Big Issue rather than straight forward begging and have a great rapport with repeat customers. The aim of the mag is to help these folk get on their feet and get a roof over their heads and in time a proper paying job once their confidence has risen. you should buy it, it has loads of interesting articles and always has a vendor profile. When I was a uni student in the U.K. I couldn’t afford cash donations so I worked at night as a volunteer in a soup kitchen. People can donate their time if they don’t have the funds, but do it in your own country, the arty farty soy latte set will take care of overseas aid!

Comments are closed.

Welcome to the Sandpit

I love a good argument so please leave a comment

Please support the Sandpit

Please support the Sandpit

Do you feel lucky?

Do you feel lucky?

%d bloggers like this: